Mathematical inquiry processes: Explore, generalise and prove; develop other lines of inquiry. Conceptual field of inquiry: ratios and equations; prime factors and lowest common multiples.
The prompt connects the concepts of a ratio and an equation. Combining the two ratios into a three-part ratio (a:b:c = 8:12:15) acts as an intermediary step from which to derive the equation. Alternatively, it is possible to convert the two ratios into separate equations (3a = 2b and 5b = 4c) and then combine them into one equation.
Students in year 10 (grade 9) classes have found the prompt intriguing. They have been enthusiastic to create more examples once they know how to show the conditional 'if-then' statement is true.
In the question, notice, and wonder phase of the inquiry, students have responded to the prompt in the following ways:
How do you work out if the equation is true?
How do you get from the ratios to the equation?
As a = 2 and b = 3 in the first ratio, 3a = 2b = 6.
a and b are not necessarily 2 and 3. They could be 12 and 18, for example.
The numbers in the ratios are consecutive. Should the numbers in the equation have the same difference?
You can combine the ratios by making b = 12 and use equivalent ratios but then the equation would be 8a = 12b = 15c.
Depending on students response to the prompt, the teacher might start the inquiry by explaining how to derive the equation from the ratios in the prompt. Alternatively, students might request an explanation by selecting the appropriate regulatory card.
In the slides, there are two ways to explain - firstly, by combining the ratios and, secondly, by converting the ratios in the prompt to equations. The second method is supported by the preparatory questions in the slides.
The combined ratio (a:b:c) is expressed as an equation by finding the lowest common multiple (LCM) of the three parts. Using prime factors, 8 = 23, 12 = 22 x 3, and 15 = 3 x 5. Thus, the LCM = 23 x 3 x 5 = 120. As b is 12 parts of the ratio, for example, it becomes 10b in the equation because 10 x 12 = 120. The slides contain a bar model that makes the equation clearer.
June 2025
A structured inquiry continues with other pairs of ratios formed with four consecutive positive integers.
Students find the combined ratio and equivalent equation. Once there are enough results to identify patterns, students can use algebraic expressions to make generalisations.
An algebraic proof follows one of the two methods from the numerical examples. For the case in the prompt, the teacher might co-construct the proof before students prove a different case (see below) independently. The teacher should note two points:
The proof does not require students to expand brackets.
The LCM of the parts of the ratio is n(n + 1)(n + 2)(n + 3).
Students can change the prompt by using the What-if-Not? Strategy from The Art of Problem Posing.
They define the new line of inquiry, generate examples in a systematic way, generalise, and prove.